Saba News News and Information from Saba Island, Dutch Caribbean
In 2020, all three islands of the Caribbean Netherlands recorded a year-on-year decrease in their goods trade deficit. St Eustatius saw the sharpest decline, followed by Bonaire and Saba. Statistics Netherlands (CBS) reports this based on newly released figures. The islands of the Caribbean Netherlands have structural trade deficits. This means more goods are imported than exported. In comparison with the European part of the Netherlands, manufacturing is relatively low in the Caribbean Netherlands. Most of the island’s income stems from (tourism) services. However, this news release focuses on goods trade.
Saba: trade deficit drops slightly
In 2020, Saba’s trade figures were similar to those in 2019. The value of imported goods (21 million US dollars) remained more or less the same, while exports increased by three-quarters. On balance, Saba’s trade deficit declined by 1 percent to 21 million US dollars last year.
St Eustatius: import value down for third year in a row
Statia’s trade deficit has decreased by one-quarter over a three-year period. In 2020, goods imports exceeded exports by 39 million US dollars. The trade deficit was 11 percent down on the previous year. The import value (-10 percent) fell for the third consecutive year and stood at 41 million US dollars in 2020. Goods exports (1 million US dollars), however, were 13 percent up on 2019.
Bonaire: first trade deficit decline in six years
In 2020, Bonaire ran a trade deficit of 236 million US dollars, i.e. 2 percent down on 2019. It is the first time in six years that the island’s trade deficit shows a year-on-year decline.
Last year, Bonaire imported goods to a total of 244 million US dollars, while exports stood at 8 million US dollars. Both imports (-4 percent) and exports (-33 percent) were down on 2019. The decline in imports was on account of machinery and transport equipment. On the export side, the decline was mainly due to fewer incoming raw materials.
Decrease in Bonaire’s trade deficit due to machinery and transport equipment
There are no indications that the decrease in Bonaire’s trade deficit, as well as Statia’s and Saba’s deficits, is a direct result of the coronavirus crisis. In fact, Bonaire had larger deficits for most goods categories in 2020 compared to the previous year. These categories also included goods that were used to deal with the crisis.
The decline in Bonaire’s trade deficit last year is entirely on account of machinery and transport equipment. In this goods category, a 24-percent lower import value resulted in a smaller trade deficit: 58 million US dollars. This was still 76 million US dollars one year previously. The only other category with a decrease in trade deficit in 2020 was mineral fuels (-23 percent). As for raw materials, the deficit notably doubled from 4 to 8 million US dollars compared to 2019.
CBS
That’s one way of looking at it. But again, CBS figures are not interpreted in the right way. More important is the question whether there goes more money to the island than from the island to the world. Unfortunately, a few years ago, a student already has pointed to the money drain of Statia. Government has done nothing to this getting poorer of the island. They are just not familiar with any monetary policy or inventing a money stream to the island. And I’m not speaking about Dutch subsidies – these are just mere subsistence measurements.
Nevertheless the falsification of the situation by using price index figures with still fixed compositions and weighing factors, could give the impression that things are getting better. But, beware, the costs of living are still too high, compared to other islands in the wide region, but also compared to the European Netherlands. Therefore many items are interrelated, like for instance the ticket prices of Winair and the cost of food on Saba and Statia.
Clearly, the not-integral approach has failed.