BIJ1 candidate Lysanne Charles: We must address colonial elephant in room

For Lysanne Charles (42), a poet, song­writer, and activist born and raised in Saba, participat­ing in the upcoming Dutch parliamentary elections on the Bill slate was an easy decision. “Since coming back to Saba four years ago and observing some of what has been happening on the island in terms of politics and government, I have been wondering how to get my ideas to another level. BIJ1 provides me that op­portunity.”

Saba candidate in the Second Chamber of the Dutch Par­liament elections Lysanne Charles.

BIJ1, the acronym in Dutch which translates to “together”, has several can­didates of Caribbean origin on the slate for the March 17 Second Chamber of the Dutch Parliament elec­tions. Party leader Sylvana Simons is from Suriname, and number two on the slate is Quinsy Gario of St. Maarten/Curacao descent. Charles is number 13. The Daily Herald spoke with her as part of a series of interviews with Windward Islands candidates in the Dutch parliamentary elec­tions.

“BIJ1 included Caribbean candidates from the onset. The party dedicates a lot of attention to the Carib­bean part of the kingdom in its party programme and addresses the issues that our people face in the Netherlands and on the islands. To me that was a real show of equality and mutual respect. I believe in the BM platform. I am an activist at heart, always de­fending the underdogs and marginalised. BIJ1 allowed and encouraged candidates who are activists from all of those groups to actually help in drafting the vari­ous sections and listened to them,” said Charles, who is the only candidate from Saba in these elections.

Creating equality

Charles shares issues that are important to BIJ1, such as the deconstructing of the colonial legacy which con­tinues to impact kingdom relations, climate change, the eradicating of poverty and racism, proper guid­ance for Dutch Caribbean students, and also women’s rights, black and brown persons’ rights, lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender and questioning (LGBTQ) rights, homeless persons’ rights and more. “If you listen to our party leader Sylvana Simons, it is really about creating equality, inclusivity and access for all these groups. It is not true that BIJ1 is only about ad­dressing racism. The party has a full programme that touches on many areas that are important to us and of­fers concrete solutions for progress.”

According to Charles, there is much work to be done in the relations be­tween the islands and the Netherlands. “What is mainly wrong in this re­lationship is that we have not ever gone back to de­termine why we are even in this relationship or rather how we got here. The Neth­erlands has been really good in not going into this matter and the islands and islanders in the diaspora did not really push for it, but for the last years have been doing so. And this is something that we need to tackle, because the origins of this relationship con­tinue to speak, in so many ways, to how we relate to each other as governments and as people and how the various governments and community stakeholders are allowed to have voice in the decision-making pro­cess,” she said.

Diverse makeup

Many in the Netherlands are steeped in the idea that both the Netherlands and the kingdom are mono-cul­tures that look and speak in only one way, while it is not so. “It is a diverse make-up actually and has been that way for centuries,” she said, referring to the fact that one quarter of the Dutch population has a parent who was not born in the Netherlands and that the Netherlands has always had port cities, which thrived on diversity.

For that reason, Charles also does not campaign in Dutch, but in the mother tongue of Saba, which is English. She pointed out that on the islands and in the Dutch Caribbean di­aspora more than one lan­guage is spoken.

“If we take it one step fur­ther and say that the Neth­erlands is the dominant fac­tor in the kingdom constel­lation, knowing that deci­sions that are made in The Hague affect all islands, we should ensure that infor­mation is transmitted in a way that is understandable to everyone. You have to make it about including all people. Only then can we talk about equality and relations that are steeped in mutual respect,” said Charles.

Fundamental discussion

The Caribbean contrib­uted a great deal of wealth to the Netherlands dur­ing the colonial times and continues to offer a lot to the Netherlands in terms of geographic position and access to various western hemisphere and small is­land state political conver­sations. That is something that requires a fundamen­tal discussion. “We inher­ited this constellation, and it is something that we need to address, in all honesty and openness and not from points of view of victims and victors, but as heirs to this legacy who want to do something to create a more equal reality.”

Some people in the Carib­bean Netherlands, includ­ing Sabans, have concerns about the islands being re-colonised, she noted. “They are of the opinion that the local authority of their leaders has eroded and that the Netherlands and Eu­ropean Dutch bureaucrats have more say than they do,” she said.

Colonial elephant

“In some instances, they are correct, in others per­haps not, but I do think that we need to, together, ad­dress the colonial elephant in the room and its legacy and talk about how we can come to a playing field that is beneficial for all of us. For me, that is not being anti-Dutch, but simply be­ing anti-colonial. There is a difference the two, because in principle I am Dutch, be­cause of the Dutch nation­ality. What I am is anti-op­pression, anti-dominance and anti-inequality.”

Colonialism is about the domination of one group over the other and it is a complex issue. “It is some­thing that we have to tackle together. People are afraid to have this conversation, because they feel that they will be made to feel guilty for things they had no role in. However, it is not about blaming, but about dismantling the structures that make the kingdom a less safe, less equal place for marginalised people, whether that is based on able-bodied vs less-abled bodied, male vs female, Caribbean vs European, educated vs uneducated, poor vs wealthy, black and brown vs white. It is about equality, justice and the well-being of persons.”

If elected, Charles has several priorities: “Advo­cate that more of a voice is returned to the local gov­ernments and populations in the decisions that are made, whereby the effects on the island and its people are taken into better con­sideration. And involve is­landers more in the Dutch government-financed proj­ects that are executed on the islands.”

Strong opposition

Charles said the objec­tive of BIJ1 was not to get into the Dutch coalition, unlike most other political parties in the Netherlands. “We will be a strong op­position, asking the ques­tions that are not being asked, disrupting the es­tablished political system. BIJ1 is also about fighting homophobia, sexism, and xenophobia. By putting the people central, it becomes an entirely different discus­sion. It needs to become, once again, more about the people of our country in the Second Chamber and not about politics for politics sake.”

Charles, who studied cul­tural anthropology and so­ciology at the University of Amsterdam and political science and mass commu­nications at the University of North Carolina at Pem­broke, said being an activist and poet has equipped her with unique skills to repre­sent the people.

“My combined experi­ences have made me even more aware of how impor­tant it is to bring people together to tackle solutions to their challenges. People bring with them all kinds of historical memory that can be coupled with new ideas to create people-centred solutions; and I must say that being a poet and a cre­ative writer has gifted me the creativity to imagine a different, better world for us all, and that is what I want to work on and will continue to work on in poli­tics and beyond.”

The Daily Herald.

Saba partially reopens on May 1
Locations and opening hours for Second Chamber Elections 2021


  1. On Surinam websites there’s so much about Sylvana Simons as a person, about what she has said, that whatever other people on her list are or say, they are considered contaminated. Unfortunately.

  2. Is she the only LHBTQIA+ candidate of Christian Saba?

    • Overly moderated comment section

      She’s the only Saban candidate running for office in Dutch elections.
      In regards to LHBTQIA+ candidates; Carl Buncamper of Saba has been an island council member for approximately 2 decades. In that time he’s also actively fought for gay rights on the island.
      (shortened by editor)

  3. No problem with one’s sexual preferences. But I do have a problem with racism, and other candidates of this party have written pretty criminal texts on social media in the Netherlands.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Saba News